Skip to content

AEO / AGENCY SELECTION

How to Choose an AEO Agency: 15 Questions to Ask

Before signing an AEO contract, ask what an agency will actually change, which claims it can verify, and how the work will be measured.

What AEO should mean in a real proposal

AEO, or answer engine optimization, describes efforts to make a business's information discoverable, useful and understandable in answer-oriented search. It does not represent a separate Google ranking system with a mandatory secret schema or a guaranteed placement service. Google's guide to optimizing for generative AI Search says normal SEO foundations and original value remain relevant.

A good proposal starts with the real questions customers ask, the pages that should answer them, and technical work needed to keep those answers accessible. If all a vendor offers is a proprietary score, an “AI citation package,” or hundreds of generic articles, the deliverables are not clear enough to buy. Google warns that mass-producing low-value pages solely to manipulate rankings can violate its spam policies.

15 questions to ask an AEO agency

1. Which URLs would you audit first?

A useful answer names commercial or informational pages and explains why they matter. A local HVAC website needs a different approach from a SaaS documentation portal. Insist on evidence from your existing site, not a generic “AI readiness” report.

2. What current problem does the audit establish?

Ask to see index coverage, canonical issues, visible service content, broken links, mobile friction or actual Search Console query trends. One chatbot answer is not proof of an ongoing traffic problem.

3. How is this different from existing SEO work?

The proposal should explicitly identify overlap with your SEO retainer. Do not pay a second fee for the same title changes, internal linking or crawl repair under another name.

4. What business facts must we approve?

Confirm services, areas served, qualifications, opening hours and prices with someone who owns those facts. A plausible AI-generated sentence is not evidence of a real service.

5. Which outcomes can you not guarantee?

Correct answers include Google rankings, Search AI links and ChatGPT recommendations. An agency can control its deliverables and QA process, not what a search system decides to surface.

6. Who writes, verifies and updates the content?

Look for an accountable reviewer, a source list, a change log and an approval process. Invented bylines and testimonials are a disqualifying risk.

7. What technical work is in scope?

Ask about readable server output, crawl access, canonical tags, internal navigation, valid structured data and broken paths. Specify who commits changes and how they are tested.

8. How will you avoid doorway and duplicate pages?

Require a distinct user need for every new URL. Replacing only a city name in dozens of nearly identical pages is not a content strategy.

9. What original proof will the website provide?

Real photographs, permissioned project evidence, clear workflows and verified client answers are stronger than invented statistics or stock reviews.

10. How will you check mobile accessibility?

Require keyboard navigation, readable headings, workable forms, meaningful image alt text, and page performance diagnostics. A page that looks polished in a mockup may still be unusable.

11. What is the baseline before work starts?

Use a fixed GSC date range, search type, target landing pages, countries and query groups. Keep qualified enquiries separate from raw impressions.

12. What does the AI visibility report measure?

Ask whether a metric comes from Google's dedicated generative AI report, from manually sampled prompts, or from third-party modeling. Never merge these into an unexplained number.

13. How will you validate actual leads?

A click on a call or WhatsApp link does not mean a conversation happened. Require proper form success events and CRM qualification definitions.

14. What is included in the price?

Name the pages, writing tasks, development time, QA, software costs, approvals, revisions and ongoing responsibilities. Compare like-for-like scopes.

15. What happens after the engagement ends?

You should retain access to written content, source code, domain controls, reports, media rights and the ability to roll back a release.

Use an evidence-based vendor scorecard

A short scoring sheet helps separate persuasive sales material from useful implementation. The weights below are a suggested buying framework, not a Google certification or industry-wide benchmark. Score each candidate from zero to five per criterion. Multiply that score by the weight and sum the results, while keeping notes about missing documentation.

CriterionWeightProof to request
Page-level diagnosis25%Named URLs, checks and findings
Implementation and testing25%Work tickets and release QA
Editorial integrity20%Sources and accountable reviewer
Measurement design20%GSC and lead definitions
Price and ownership10%Clear handover and inclusions

Do not treat an overall high score as permission to overlook serious risks. Fake credentials, guaranteed search rankings or a refusal to identify the work are reasons to reject a proposal even when the quote is attractive.

Red flags, and a sensible first engagement

  • Guaranteed placement in ChatGPT or a promise of ranking number one in Google.
  • Duplicate city landing pages created without locally useful information.
  • Client case studies without dates, permission or verifiable project evidence.
  • An “AI schema” supposedly required for Google AI Overviews.
  • Long retainers with no page-level deliverables, acceptance tests or documented exit.

A smaller discovery engagement may be enough to test a new supplier. Ask for an annotated audit of three business-critical pages, a prioritized fix list and one implemented change that can be inspected in staging. Require a clear difference between defects found, work completed and potential benefits. Only expand when the first results demonstrate competent delivery.

Compare the proposed work with our AEO pricing and scope guide. If a site has almost no organic visibility, read the Search Console diagnostic before buying a rewrite package.

What should the statement of work contain?

A useful statement of work lists actual URLs, content sources, technical changes, who approves factual claims, whether staging is available, which page templates are affected, and the end-of-project handover. Include a release rollback path and a timeline for checking indexing or conversion impacts without promising that a search engine will act by a specific deadline.

For AEO specifically, distinguish improvements to page accessibility and usefulness from manual observations of AI answers. The same query can yield different answers for different users or contexts. A fair performance report notes that uncertainty instead of inventing a permanent “AI rank.”

See ThreeZero AEO services or ask for a scoped website review. The goal is a useful change list that a business owner can independently verify.

Primary references

Google Search Central: helpful, reliable, people-first content; AI features and your website; and spam and doorway policies.